I'd rather lose playing fair than win cheating..as thats really not winning.....Well said agent Brent Hollett

I'd rather lose playing fair than win cheating..as thats really not winning.....Well said agent Brent Hollett 

Originally shared by Brent Hollett (Perringaiden)

Cheating and the Ingress TOS

Ingress Terms of Service: http://www.ingress.com/terms
Ingress Community Guidelines: https://support.google.com/ingress/answer/2808360?hl=en&ref_topic=2799231

From the Community Guidelines:
Cheating: Don't do it. Play fair. Only use official Niantic Labs software and remember Ingress is meant to be played on a mobile device and get you outside to explore your world! Methods of cheating, unfortunately, are limited only by cheaters' imaginations, but include at a minimum the following: using modified or unofficial software, playing with multiple accounts (one account per player, please); sharing accounts; win trading; using tools or techniques to alter or falsify your location; or selling or trading accounts. If you suspect someone of cheating, don't call them out in Comm or demand they show their face, just report it via the Help Center and focus on your mission.

Just a reminder folks.  With the influx of new players, we have a responsibility to encourage people to stick to playing by the rules.  We should play a clean, fair game, and anyone caught cheating should be reported and asked not to be involved in our Ingress experience.

Forms of cheating include:
* Win trading with opposition players to level:  If you need help levelling, ask your local team. Your local communities will have many people willing to come and assist you.
* Account sharing: Hacking for someone else who isn't physically present, using someone else's account to attack portals at double strength etc, is cheating.  One person, one account.  
* Muling: Creating fake accounts with the purpose of using them to store spare or additional items.  Accounts for real players like wives, and children who actually can play are fine, and many will get their significant other to hold onto gear for them, but creating accounts with no unique individual behind them is not acceptable.  One person, one account.
* Multiple Accounts: Having multiple accounts that you use to play is cheating.  In Ingress a P8 requires 8 players to create. Having 2 or 3 accounts goes against the spirit of the game.  One person, one account.
* Spoofing: Using software to alter your location from the actual physical location of the player is not acceptable in any form.  The spirit of Ingress is to explore, to travel and to experience new locations and adventures.  If sitting at home on your PC is exciting, go back to Call of Duty or World of Warcraft.  We are part of the real world, and we deserve for our fellow players to have to go to the same effort as we do to succeed.
* Real Money Trading: If you see people selling gear for real money, report it.  Gear can only be obtained by hacking, or being donated by other legitimate players who hacked the gear up.  Don't buy bursters because you can't get the time to farm, work together with your fellow players to make the portals you need to gear.  Teamwork is cheaper than any bot selling bursters.
* Scripts or third party apps: Broot Mod and other game altering tools received sweeping bans, so if you don't like playing for much longer, feel free to use them, otherwise stick to the legitimate client.  Same goes for drop tools, and any other script that automates your gameplay on the phone.  If it touches the client or simulates client actions, don't do it.
* Anything else that's not legit: If you're not sure, then odds are good its against the ToS. Ask someone if you really want to do it and still aren't sure.

Caveats:
* Passenger Hacking: For road safety, its generally accepted that someone in a vehicle can hack and act for the driver of the vehicle.  The account owner must be physically present, but in order to keep their attention on the road and not the phone, most people accept that the passenger can use the account.  Niantic cannot detect this, but that's not a justification for it.  Its accepted purely for a safety reason.  (This is a personal opinion.  Niantic's rule is no.)
* IITC: Ingress Intel Total Conversion is a "ToS breaching" tool that is used around the world for operations and other activities purely because the raw Intel map is so broken.  If you're unsure or don't need its functionality, stay away from it, and if you do use it, keep it well up to date, and pay attention to the communities.  The only time people have been banned due to IITC was when a bugged mobile client was causing the device to hammer the Intel servers.  People got suspended initially but those who didn't update their client and kept trying to use it got banned.   #ratheruseiitc  

Conclusion:  Cheating is bad, don't do it.  We'd prefer to lose without cheating, than win with it.
http://www.ingress.com/terms

Comments

  1. Hollow victories are just that, hollow.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I Have always played fair, It would be useless to do anything Else, As much Money Time & Gas I spent doing so, I'd be Very Angry If I caught someone cheating

    ReplyDelete
  3. "For road safety, its generally accepted that someone in a vehicle can hack and act for the driver of the vehicle."

    Generally accepted by whom, might I ask?

    ReplyDelete
  4. Was talking briefly with the local "bot lord" of Miami. He don't care. Non of them do. They have different set of values. Nothing that we can say/do will work. They enjoy trolling/ cheating.

    It's NIA Ops job to govern. Nothing we the field agents can do. We just learn to ignore it and shake or heads as new players quit.
    Just my $0.02 Joe Philley

    ReplyDelete
  5. the bot lords were what I was discussing with Brent Hollett when he made this post. I'm grateful to him. Its not a local thing for anyone, they are all over. I think most of us would like to know what we can do locally and as players to make it easy for NIA to shut them down. (can we get some feedback on that Joe?) A lot of people are discouraged but lets look at possible solutions and work together across factions rather than grousing and complaining. It starts with defining the cheating as bad behavior and being willing to speak out against it. Then we have to be willing to reject those who insist on the behavior. Don't play their portals. Refuse to play with them. Don't hack their stuff, Jarvis or ada it and rebuild it. Identify them and be willing to hope for and work for reform while maintaining zero tolerance for the cheating play. It isn't enough. I know that. But we have to do what we can do.

    ReplyDelete
  6. My issue is with Niantic. I have repeatedly reported players in my area who were cheating. I included screenshots of their win trading & other violations but nothing was ever done to them. One of them even put my real name & where I live in open comms. It's extremely discouraging for those of us who play by the rules.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I agree. Go out and see the world (and hack of course). It's much more interesting than trying to bend and break the rules.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Anne Miles don't play with their portals isn't possible at this time. Our guy can build a green/blue l8 farm and he's all over. Remember bots aren't anchored to a region. They can lvl up anywhere

    At this time were just grinding water. Nothing we can do. Ppl get upset, they shouldn't. Ours a game and like any other game ppl play it differently. Cheaters/ trolls will cheat and troll in any game. It's up to NIA to fix. I can't keep track of my local looser bot guy

    ReplyDelete
  9. Adam Howard Agreed. Far as I can see, whoever the driver gives their phone or account to is multi accounting.

    Designated drivers for drunks don't get to drink, designated drivers for agents don't get to let someone else play for them.

    They are simply trying to justify cheating.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Most of our Mega Fields have been killed by spoofers. And sometimes its the same spoofer over and over... Yes Niantic has banned a couple of them after numerous complaints and several fields spoofed down but this still doesn't fix the problem.

    Since 99% of Mega Fields in our area are spoofed down. Why doesn't NIA Ops develop a new portal Mod like a Very Rare "Anti-Virus" mod which makes a portal 100% immune to virus attacks. That way spoofers will have a much harder time spoofing down fields.

    Just an idea. But it isn't cool when so much time and money are put into a Mega Field to watch Spoofer take it down in seconds.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Brent Hollett You negated your entire "don't cheat" stance by saying "if you use IITC, keep it up to date..." If you use IITC, you ARE cheating. #rogueteam

    ReplyDelete
  12. Yvonne Varwig nia are OK with iitc. Was confirmed with nia a while back

    ReplyDelete
  13. Yvonne Varwig Misinformed people are misinformed.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Lio Ryte they are not "ok" with it. They tolerate it's use since so much people use it that banning IITC users would negatively affect the game's userbase.

    That said, if you want to see how "ok" they are with it, make a user script that refreshes every .1 of a second,  run it during an anomaly, and see how long your account survives being banned

    ReplyDelete
  15. Mario Valenzuela II they are yes "OK" with it, bit this is irrelevant to the post

    ReplyDelete
  16. I think it is entirely relevant to the post. IITC is a cheat, using it makes you a cheater. #RogueTeam

    ReplyDelete
  17. Tolerating something doesn't mean you are "OK" with it.  It means you have to deal with it even though it you hate that the thing exists. If every IITC user got banned for cheating the drop in active users would be so devastating that Google might ask Niantic, "What the fuck do you think you are doing?"

    ReplyDelete
  18. I've learned a lot from this....

    1. It's not OK to cheat.

    2. It is OK to cheat.

    Did I miss anything?

    ReplyDelete
  19. I think that about covers it, but I think we should double check with Chaz Walker

    ReplyDelete
  20. On the whole, I agree with OP and Joe Philly. I stick with stock apps, personally (don't have a choice now I'm on an iPhone), but I don't begrudge others who choose the path of iitc.

    I would, still, love to hear if it's true that Joe Philley runs IAGO (either to dismiss the IAGO users argument that it's okay because Joe runs it, or to dismiss Joe's stances on guardian hunting.)

    ReplyDelete
  21. Chaz Walker IAGO is not on my lists of things I do :) I use our app at all times only

    ReplyDelete
  22. Chaz Walker Just an FYI I was #12 on the resistance list for the day at Galveston and I only use my scanner(and took 470 images) when not playing a had a shrimp lunch and fueled my car up.

    ReplyDelete
  23. Yeah, and you didn't even bring me a souvenir! Joe Philley ;)

    ReplyDelete
  24. That is fantastic to hear Joe!

    Aside from dismissing the IAGO users claims that you use it, it also cements my belief that you're a great guy. =)

    ReplyDelete
  25. Robert Hughes I've picked up a few things myself.

    1. IITC is cheating because it's an Intel option that actually works!

    2. Based on Chaz Walker comment, it should also be stated that using GPS and Ingress is also cheating! You should not use anything besides the scanner to find a portal. That is why it has the HIGHLY useful "Navigate" feature.

    3. Cars should not be allowed, because not all players have cars, so that is an unfair advantage to those on foot. Actually, even having legs is an advantage that not everyone has the luxury of. Better nix walking as well.

    ReplyDelete
  26. Mario Valenzuela II If you generate too much traffic on the intel server you will be autobanned, has nothing to do with IITC. We had players being banned while using STOCK intel for OP during anomalies or fielding, just because they refreshed too much. Talk to Niantic and the ban usually is gone.

    ReplyDelete
  27. We have quite the grand assortment of multi account users (in every form expressed above) in our city. The unfortunate side is how difficult it can be to prove, and how malicious people can be with false claims. I have reported only one player for it, and only after witnessing it in action. Unfortunately, said agent still cheats, because NIA Ops has no way of verifying my claims, no matter how legitimate.

    However, "Passenger Hacking" I would say is bad. Many times I have read "spirit of the game" and I cheer, however seeing anything condoning vehicular ingressing is quite the opposite. This game isn't about getting behind the wheel. Keep the spirit of the game, and use your two feet to farm, not your car.

    ReplyDelete
  28. Devin Langford originally posted:

    Blah blah blah, it's okay if I cheat, blah blah blah.

    ReplyDelete
  29. Andrew Risenhoover With the way the game is played people use cars, simple as that. And it's technically legitimate to drive and hack, but I'd prefer to see people not crash.

    This is my interpretation of the rules, you're welcome to present your own, in a reasonable and respectful way.

    ReplyDelete
  30. Oh I'm not saying it's cheating to drive and hack, I'm saying it sullied the spirit of the game. Plus, it's illegal in most states, and those it's not, it should be.

    ReplyDelete
  31. Mario Valenzuela II IITC as implemented on the official site will not get you banned. They accept that at least till they can fix their own map to be good enough. What they will not tolerate is degrading server performance which is why your script would get you banned and partly why the TOS rule exists. They can't approve IITC officially because it's open ended but if you abide by the restrictions the IITC team hold themselves to, you're actually causing less traffic for the server and well within the safe use.

    ReplyDelete
  32. If an official app appeared that was better than the mobile browser crushing intel map (just loading the intel map on my iPad 2 3G kills the browser's process, so i literally have no way to use intel on my iPad) people probably would leave IITC alone, at least on the mobile.

    ReplyDelete
  33. I agree with Andrew Risenhoover.

    However.

    I'm going to continue doing the lions share of my ingressing from a vehicle.

    because getting 200,000 hacks on foot would just take way too long.

    ReplyDelete
  34. Some on this post should pay attention to spoofing is cheating.

    ReplyDelete
  35. Awwww. Are you still doing that whole, "Konfusion is a spoofer" disinformation campaign?

    And I thought losing several of your best players would stifle that idea. Silly me.

    Keep creating ride attendants I suppose. Every smurf needs to ride the pony, and some fake account of Mo's needs to make sure it happens!

    ReplyDelete
  36. Good thing Moe has Moe to pat Moe's back.

    ReplyDelete
  37. Chaz Walker of all the players I've played with, in many states, Chaz Walker is the least likely to follow the spoofers, cheaters or players who cheat.. He is the resident TOS rules advisor...

    ReplyDelete
  38. Ross Fulton, you quoted Brent Hollett, not NIA Ops.

    Niantic officially says, "playing with multiple accounts (one account per player, please); sharing accounts;"


    This is a grey area. Joe Philly agrees with Brent, and I agree with Joe.

    As long as the driver is L8 or higher, I have no objections with the passenger deploying/hacking for that player, and I would never report/consider such behavior as cheating.

    Now, if the driver is L7 or below, and some other player is just playing for them to get to their level 8.... Then it's cheating.

    ReplyDelete
  39. Ah, I assumed he has pulled those from the official documents.  I've only been playing for about a month now, so haven't gorged on all there is, yet.  Thanks, Chaz Walker.

    My prior statement is redacted.

    ReplyDelete
  40. Ross Fulton Yes, everything from "Just a reminder" onwards is my own interpretation of the Community Guidelines.  They are rather thin on the forms of cheating, thus the reason for this post.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog